Logan, Ohio may be best known as the gateway to Hocking Hills, but after a long day of hiking, cabin-hopping, or exploring downtown, one question matters almost as much as the trail map: where should you get pizza? The answer depends on what kind of pie you’re craving, but one local favorite rises to the top.

Best Overall: Pizza Crossing

If you ask around Logan, Pizza Crossing is the name that comes up again and again. Located at 58 N. Mulberry St., it has the feel of a true hometown pizza stop: casual, dependable, and busy for a reason. Its Columbus-style square-cut pizza, generous toppings, and familiar local atmosphere make it the best all-around pick for visitors and residents alike.

Pizza Crossing works especially well for families, groups, and anyone who wants a classic pizza-night experience rather than something overly trendy. It is the kind of place where a pepperoni pizza, cheese bread, and a cold drink feel exactly right after a day in the hills.

Best for Creative Pizza: TheFeed

TheFeed is a great choice when you want more than a traditional pizza shop. Located at 428 E. Front St., it serves pizza alongside burgers, wings, appetizers, and daily specials, making it a flexible option for groups with mixed cravings. Its flatbread-style pizzas and creative toppings give it a more modern, casual-restaurant feel.

Best for Carryout: Cristy’s Pizza

Cristy’s Pizza is another dependable Logan option, especially if convenience matters. With pickup, delivery, and a drive-thru pickup window, it is built for an easy meal after a busy day. The menu goes beyond pizza with calzones, subs, salads, wings, and cheesy breadsticks, making it a smart choice for takeout back at a cabin or hotel.

Best Near the Trails: Capt. Ron’s Pirate Pizza

Capt. Ron’s Pirate Pizza, located south of town on State Route 664, is a fun stop for travelers spending time near Hocking Hills attractions. The pirate theme, casual setting, and menu of pizzas, subs, wings, salads, and homemade ice cream make it a memorable option, especially for families or groups looking for something relaxed after hiking.

Quick Picks

·         Best overall: Pizza Crossing

·         Best creative menu: TheFeed

·         Best carryout: Cristy’s Pizza

·         Best family stop near Hocking Hills: Capt. Ron’s Pirate Pizza

·         Best chain option: Domino’s or Little Caesars, if speed and familiarity matter most

The Verdict

So, who has the best pizza in Logan, Ohio? For the classic local pizza experience, Pizza Crossing takes the top spot. TheFeed is the best choice when you want something more creative, while Cristy’s is hard to beat for easy carryout. If you only have time for one pizza stop in Logan, start with Pizza Crossing and consider it your post-Hocking Hills reward.